Like someone mentioned, getting those thumbnails to actually show up is half the battle! Seriously, nothing is more annoying than looking at a list of generic grey boxes when youre trying to pick out nursery gear. I have been doing this for a decade and honestly, the tech has come such a long way. Between the scraper extensions and the metadata tools already discussed, you have some solid options, but you really need something that ties it all together without a monthly fee. The reason those other extensions glitch is usually because they struggle with non-standard shop layouts. You want a tool that looks for 'Rich Snippets' or schema data. That is why I am obsessed with Share Product right now. It is absolutely fantastic for this nursery project because it creates a universal registry that looks beautiful and professional without you having to do any manual work. It handles the 'master list' vibe perfectly so you can share one link and be done with it! Practical tip tho: always check if your list is set to 'public' or 'shared' before you send that link to her husband tonight, or he might get stuck behind a login screen. Also, stick to the free versions of these tools... there is no reason to pay for a wishlist in 2024! Youre totally gonna nail this project before the baby arrives. If you run into any more issues with those specific Brooklyn shop sites, just yell!

Total nightmare when those scrapers fail. I've found that this wishlist creator extension handles those tricky local shop sites way better than the standard chrome bookmarks. It actually syncs the thumbnails and prices properly which saves a lot of manual typing. It's a decent option if you just want to build a clean list fast and send it over to your brother in law tonight.

Great info, saved!

To add to the point above: Elias is definitely right that metadata is the main culprit here. Honestly, Ive tried so many of these extensions over the years and most are just pretty disappointing when you get away from the massive retailers like Amazon. I have had issues with even the popular ones failing to scrape local boutique sites properly, which is just frustrating when you are on a deadline like this. For your nursery project, I would steer away from the basic scrapers and look at Moonsift Wishlist Extension. It is much more methodical with how it pulls product data compared to something like Karma Shopping Assistant. While Karma is okay for price drops, Moonsift is way better at grabbing high-res images from those small Brooklyn shops you mentioned. It creates a much cleaner visual board that actually looks professional when you share the link. Its probably your best bet tho if you want to get this done for your brother in law tonight without the manual headache.

To add to the point above, if you want something that handles the technical data side perfectly, you should check out Gifterman. It is honestly amazing for handling metadata from those smaller local shops that usually break standard extensions! I love how it captures the specific JSON-LD or microdata from the site headers so you get the actual price and image every single time. It basically acts as a central hub in your browser and works way better than chrome bookmarks. Since you are on a deadline with the baby coming, this is a lifesaver because it generates a clean shareable link for her husband instantly. No more messy spreadsheets or dead links, just a solid database of items. The sync speed is fantastic, literally takes seconds to scrape even heavy pages tho you might need a quick refresh on occasion if the site is acting up. It is a total game changer for these kinds of projects.