Just spent like 4 hours looking at eBay listings for bulk Lego and honestly I am so annoyed. Everywhere I look online—YouTube videos, Reddit threads, etc—people are super polarized about this. Some swear by buying 10lb lots on eBay and say they find hidden gems like old Star Wars figs or rare baseplates. Then I click on another forum post and everyone is like dont bother, you will just get 5lbs of MegaBloks and hair and chewed up plastic. It is driving me crazy because I cant tell if these people just got unlucky or if the good lots are actually impossible to find. I am trying to get back into building stuff for my desk, nothing specific, just general building.
Im working with some strict constraints here:
Like, does anyone actually have a system for vetting these sellers? Do you just look at the photo and guess? Every time I see a good price the shipping is insane, or the photo is blurry and looks like it was taken on a potato. Is it actually cheaper than just buying sets on clearance or using Pick a Brick? I feel like Im gonna waste my money on literal trash if I pull the trigger tonight. Is it really worth the gamble or am I better off just buying specific colors from BrickLink...
Re: "Man, I feel your pain. I tried the..."
Man, I feel your pain. I tried the eBay gamble a few times when I started back up and honestly, it is mostly a headache. Unless you find a local pickup listing where you can actually see the tote, I would stay away. Youre totally right about the shipping cost—Midwest shipping on 10lbs of plastic that might end up being half trash just isnt worth the math. If you have a hard $200 cap and want to build MOCs for your desk, you are much better off hitting up BrickLink or even Legos own Pick a Brick service. Yeah, it feels less like a treasure hunt than buying a big grab bag, but you actually get what you need. With bulk lots, you spend hours sorting, scrubbing, and throwing away hair and off-brand knockoffs. It sucks the fun right out of building. If you really want the bulk feel, check out local Facebook Marketplace listings instead of eBay. You can at least ask the seller to send a photo of the bricks dumped out or verify if there are any MegaBloks mixed in. Plus, no shipping costs. But for real, save yourself the stress and just order specific plates and bricks. You can get a massive amount of variety for $200 if you arent paying for the weight of random trash.
Honestly, I went down the eBay bulk route last month and it was not as good as expected. Actually, it was super disappointing. I had issues with dirty off-brand bricks and tons of broken parts, even though the listing photo looked clean. If you have a hard $200 cap and need it soon, unfortunately it is just too risky. Here is why bulk lots usually fail: