I need a grip for my 5D Mark IV like... yesterday. Ive been shooting weddings for about six years now and honestly I always just carried extra batteries in my pocket but this Saturday I have a massive 12-hour gig in Seattle and my wrist is already killing me just thinking about all the vertical portraits.
So I was thinking about just grabbing the official Canon BG-E20 but man it is so expensive for what it is. My logic was maybe I could save some cash with a Vello or Neewer one since I just dropped two grand on a new 24-70mm and I'm feeling the burn in my wallet right now. But then I started reading about these third party ones having issues and now I'm second guessing everything. Here is what I'm worried about:
I really need that extra battery life but I'm terrified a cheap one will fail mid-ceremony or just feel like cheap plastic. Does the Canon one really justify the price jump or is there a specific third party one that actually feels identical to the camera body? I'm running out of time to order before the weekend so I really need to decide tonight...
Honestly, for a 12-hour wedding gig in Seattle where it might rain, I would be really careful with the cheap stuff. I tried a Neewer NW-5D Mark IV Battery Grip a while back and the joystick felt like a toy. It was super frustrating during fast sequences because it would lag or just miss clicks entirely. When youre shooting a ceremony, you really cant be fighting your gear. If you go third party, make sure to consider these risks:
Building on the earlier suggestion, I totally get the wallet pain after buying glass, but the Canon BG-E20 Battery Grip is honestly a different world compared to the cheap ones. That grip has been on my camera for about two years now and I'm super satisfied with how it handles. When you're shooting a marathon 12-hour day, you really dont want to be second-guessing if your shutter is gonna fire or if the joystick is gonna lag. Cheap alternatives usually feel like hollow plastic toys. Here is why I stick with the official one:
Been thinking about your dilemma and honestly, I've been down this road many times. In my experience, the real issue isnt just the plastic feeling, it is the electronic communication. I used to try to save money on accessories until a third-party grip I was using on an older body started draining my Canon LP-E6N Lithium-Ion Battery while the camera was turned off... super annoying when you wake up for a shoot and youre already low on power. I once compared the Canon BG-E20 Battery Grip side-by-side with the Vello BG-C14 Battery Grip for Canon 5D Mark IV. The Vello is probably the best of the third-party ones, but the buttons just didnt have that distinct click the 5D body has. When you are shooting in the rain in Seattle, you need to feel that tactile feedback through your fingers without looking. Plus, the weather sealing on the official one uses the same gaskets as the camera. Tbh, if you are shooting a high-stakes 12-hour wedding, the risk of a cheap grip shorting out your main body is just too high. I always stick with the brand name for electronics now. Its just safer... One more thing to watch out for is that the third-party pins often dont align perfectly, which can cause the camera to randomly restart if you bump the grip. Its not worth the stress on a wedding day.
Can confirm this works. Did the same thing on mine and its been solid ever since.
Good to know!
Re: Good to know!
Ngl I saw this and had to jump in because weddings are just brutal on the body! I totally get the wallet pain after that lens purchase but honestly for a big 12-hour gig in Seattle you gotta be so careful!! I think I remember hearing that the weather sealing on those cheaper third-party grips is basically non-existent compared to the magnesium alloy stuff. If it starts pouring and water gets into that battery tray because the seal isnt tight... that could be a total disaster for your camera body! IIRC the official ones have actual rubber gaskets around the communication pins and the door to keep things dry. I'm not 100% sure if any budget brands actually match that level of build quality but I'd be way too scared to risk a pro body on a rainy day with a thin plastic tray. The joystick response is everything too! If it lags even a tiny bit you're gonna miss the kiss!